2nd Gen Pick one of these three.

[WhiteLioness]

In Generation 2, we were introduced to 3 Pokemon who would either breathe fire, shoot water or throw sharp leaves!

So which one of these were your favorites? :)

Cyndaquil

Totodile

Or Chikorita?

Excuse me, but this board is about the generation 1 games, not generation 2. This topic does not belong here and it should be moved.

 

[nesinomics]

As a kid I always went for totodile but now I will always go for cyndaquil.

 

[keep--sailing]

I originally started with Totodile..no idea why, but I normally always go with the Water-Type first time through and always end up playing with the Grass-Type second time around. Definitely Chikorita though.

 

[Raging Umbreon]

Totodile line is my favorite starter in Gen 2. Feraligatr is my favorite water type.

 

[bewbs]

In Silver I chose Chikorita which is my favourite starter out of the three.
In Gold I pickd Cyndaquil.
In Crystal I picked Totodile.

 

[Sefuree]

Mine is cyndaquil! I Also like totodile.
The first game i had was HG/SS so i dont really know what it really feels like. Lol

 

[Limey-chan]

Totodile.

I'm surprised at how many people have chosen lil Totes in this thread; I always under the impression that Cyndaquil (ugh) was the most popular of the Gen 2 starters by far.

 

[Pinta77]

First crystal playthrough, I went totodile!

 

[Mikekillkill]

Simply... Cyndaquil was my starter because, it was my cup of tea, but knowing bulbasaur from GEN 1 as a Damage and Status stacker, Chikorita would be the same... Now for Totadile, even though he has the early rush aspect with his moveset, also surf. I wanted to play the game, without Stacking or Rushing, As Totadile would be crushing the XP curve way too fast with his moveset, Cyndaquil makes up for it's slow moveset with learning a accuracy crushing move (Good early game) and ember being pretty useful... I Knew i just had to pick cyndaquil, Also I like its design :P (Too much RTS XD)

 

[PokeHunterBlack]

Well, when i first played that gen i would pick cydaquil for the evolution, but then i would go to totodile for strengh and the games are a breeze whit feralagator, but right now i am doing a solo with cydaquil no evolving so i would say cydaqiul

 

[pyx]

Totodile and Cyndaquil are my favorite.

 

[Codename Peace]

Definitely Cyndaquil, and its evolutions,

 

[AANickFan]

Back in the day (3 years ago) I didn't really know what Pokemon was. I was 7-8 years old. When I picked a starter, I picked Totodile. I don't remember anything else. If I never played Pokemon HeartGold 3 years ago and picked Totodile, I would choose Cyndaquil. But history has brought my heart to Totodile. I always pick Totodile when I play Johto games.

 

[Tirion]

Gotta go with Chikorita. Loved its evolutions. The other two, not so much (which is weird considering Gen 2 is my favorite).

I love Totodile, but really dislike Croconaw and Feraligatr. I like Cyndaquil, and really like Quilava, but for some reason I just find Typhlosion boring.

 

[Charizard :P]

When I first played Crystal, I chose Totodile, but my favourite would have to be the Cyndaquil line. Typhlosion in particular. It isn't used as much as the other starters, but I personally love Typhlosion! :D

 

[Emboar]

Cyndaquil. The only generation where I my favorite starter isn't Fire type in Gen 6.

 

[La Espada]

The water type starter has been my favorite in every gen except 2nd. I like Feraligatr but Typhlosion was my favorite by far.

 

[javcdark]

cyndaquil>totodile, i never played with chikorita

 

[CJoE]

When the first time i played Pokemon Crystal, i chose Chikorita cause he's kinda cute to me. After i raise it to its first evolution (i forgot the name). I replay back the game and chose Totodile, he been my most strongest pokemon throughout the game. haha~

 

[Humble Hook]

The Totodile evo line is my favorite starter of all, and also my fav pokemon of all as well.
Well, just Totodile and Feraligator. Croconaw is just a waste of space.