Newer is not always better. In another couple years, Enterbrain will come out with ANOTHER version of RPG Maker and we'll be having this same discussion again. It's like how people convert to D/P graphics just for the sake of doing so, even if they're using Pokémon Essentials where 80x80 pixel graphics resized look horribly distorted.
People will use the limitations of RPG Maker XP as an excuse to switch over, but how many people have surpassed the limit of 999 items? How about maps? And Pokémon? You get the idea. How about actually FINISHING at least one game with Pokémon Essentials/RPG Maker XP? If people can't even do this, then they shouldn't worry about how many different ways they can make things even more complicated for themselves. I don't see ONE Pokémon fangame on PokéCommunity being finished within the next few years. Silver Chronicles could be, but victorspvl insists on keeping it going forever...
How about a Sphere or Game Maker starter kit instead? They would both be better options because of how much control you get. With these two, you also don't have to spend weeks scripting a mouse function similar to the DS stylus because the foundation is already there.
This all has to do with everyone's desire for the MOST and BEST of everything. In this case, they want to fulfill their desires of creating the PERFECT game, with the MOST features, BEST engine, and the GREATEST Pokémon game that has ever been made. Is it that bad to work with what you already have? No matter what anyone says, Nintendo has made really amazing games despite all the limitations of the hardware they have used. Would you want them to keep upgrading and adding on, trying to make the perfect game? Even if it means you'll never be able to enjoy ONE complete game because of the inevitability of improvements in technology, Nintendo will NEVER be finished with anything?
Whatever happened to working with what you already have? I know RPG Maker XP has a lot of limitations, but you could use it to do great things and make a game that's truly exceptional. Yes, some people will argue that you can make a BETTER one with RPG Maker VX, but that alone is not a good justification for upgrading for the sake of upgrading.
Also, how many people who voted in favor of your idea have substantial experience in working with RMVX? To those who say no, I will never accept their reasoning until they can prove to me that they can do things on RMVX as well as they can on RMXP.