Winter Pixel Contest [Stage 1 : Voting]

[Fairy]

Well, my original intention was that each person judges all of them, the same way I did in my post and Nina in hers. Then I'd take the average of the total scores and call it good. But if that's too complicated I guess we could work out a different voting scheme? I don't want to over burden everyone. ;;

 

[esperance]

It's not too much of a burden or anything. Although I don't think I'm the most qualified judge. :s

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 3
Execution: 2
Concept: 3
Total: 8

Wizardman11

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 12

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 4
Concept: 5
Total: 14

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 3
Execution: 3
Concept: 3
Total: 9

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Milotic

Complexity: 3
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 11

countryemo

Complexity: 5
Execution: 4
Concept: 5
Total: 14​

 

[Universe]

nice nice nice!!

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 2
Execution: 2
Concept: 2
Total: 6

Wizardman11

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 12

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 3
Execution: 4
Concept: 3
Total: 10

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Milotic

Complexity: 2
Execution: 3
Concept: 2
Total: 7

countryemo

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 12

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 3
Execution: 3
Concept: 2
Total: 8​

 

[Draskk]

Hi ima judge these real quick

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 2
Execution: 2
Concept: 2
Total: 6

Wizardman11

Complexity: 4
Execution: 5
Concept: 4
Total: 13

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 3
Execution: 3
Concept: 3
Total: 9

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Milotic

Complexity: 3
Execution: 4
Concept: 3
Total: 10

countryemo

Complexity: 5
Execution: 4
Concept: 5
Total: 14

Good Job yall

 

[countryemo]

Here are my votes~

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 2
Execution: 2
Concept: 3
Total: 7

Wizardman11

Complexity: 5
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 13

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 4
Concept: 5
Total: 14

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 3
Execution: 4
Concept: 3
Total: 10

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Milotic

Complexity: 3
Execution: 3
Concept: 3
Total: 9

 

[Strange]

These were all great!

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 2
Execution: 3
Concept: 3
Total: 8

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 4
Total: 14

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 3
Execution: 4
Concept: 3
Total: 10

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Milotic

Complexity: 3
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 13

countryemo

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 2
Total: 10

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 2
Total: 10​

 

[Ice1]

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 2
Execution: 4
Concept: 2
Total: 8

Wizardman11

Complexity: 4
Execution: 2
Concept: 4
Total: 10

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 2
Execution: 4
Concept: 2
Total: 8

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 4
Total: 14

Milotic

Complexity: 4
Execution: 3
Concept: 4
Total: 11

countryemo

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 3
Total: 11

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 3
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 11​

Tadaa~ Nina's my favorite

 

[GiovanniViridian]

Sorry for my late voting, I assume I can't vote for mine but here goes:

Spoiler:

Wizardman11

Complexity: 4
Execution: 4
Concept: 5
Total: 13

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 4
Concept: 3
Total: 12

Dugtrio-Ramen

Complexity: 2
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 10

Nina

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Milotic

Complexity: 4
Execution: 3
Concept: 4
Total: 11

countryemo

Complexity: 4
Execution: 3
Concept: 4
Total: 11

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 4
Execution: 3
Concept: 4
Total: 11​

 

[Fairy]

-

-

Oh, you guys left out Hopeless Masquerade's entry for your posts. Could you real quick put in a vote for the sprite please? :)

 

[Draskk]

Ok

Spoiler:

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 2
Execution: 3
Concept: 3
Total: 8

 

[Dugtrio-Ramen]

Good thing I saw this today, I didn't know we had to vote.
You said we can't vote for ourselves so i took mine out.
I see some really nice ones that i think are gonna win.
These are my scores for each, sorry if i got some totals wrong, i rushed through them.

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian

Complexity: 2
Execution: 2
Concept: 4
Total: 8

Wizardman11

Complexity: 5
Execution: 3
Concept: 5
Total: 13

Ice

Complexity: 5
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 15

Nina

Complexity: 4
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 14

Milotic

Complexity: 2
Execution: 4
Concept: 4
Total: 10

countryemo

Complexity: 3
Execution: 5
Concept: 5
Total: 13

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 2
Execution: 5
Concept: 3
Total: 10​

 

[countryemo]

Who's to say I didn't do it on purpose? :P Joke's I quoted Drask, its their fault. :x

Spoiler:

Hopeless Masquerade

Complexity: 2
Execution: 2
Concept: 3
Total: 7

 

[Fairy]

❅ Thanks Everyone!

Let's give a big congratulations to everyone who participated in this phase of the contest! I really loved seeing some of the concepts and designs you came up with and your hard work is very appreciated! I'm going to open this by announcing this round's winners and follow up with the total of everyone's scores.​

❄ 1st Place : Nina

❄ 2nd Place : Ice

❄ 3rd Place : Wizardman11 & countryemo

❄ The Scores

Here's the total of everyone's scores as I have calculated them.

Spoiler:

GiovanniViridian = 7.5
Wizardman11 = 12
Ice = 14
Dugtrio-Ramen = 9.1
Nina = 14.7
Milotic = 11.5
Countryemo = 12
Hopeless Masquerade = 9.5

❅ Congratulations!

You'll have some time before Stage 2 goes up, in which case your totals from this contest will be added to your final score, so it's not too late to move up in the contest! Keep working everyone, you're doing great! Thanks again so much for your support and participation. Everyone who participated in this stage will receive a notification when stage 2 goes up. You don't have to participate, but it would be appreciated (especially if you want to keep your winning score, hehe). Congratulations to everyone and, again, thank you. <3​

​

​

​

 

[Ice1]

Congratz Nina! You're thingy looks amazing, although I would've liked to win myself :p

 

[GiovanniViridian]

Congrats to Nina and the other participants!

and now that I have the lowest score I'll probably move there in the corner lol

 

[Nina]

Thanks so much guys! : ) Good luck to everyone in the next round.

 

[countryemo]

B-b-but I wanted to beat Nina! D: Jokes aside, hers is really nice, I really like her ideas. I knew mine had problems before uploading, I just wanted to make the date, it could've had more contrast and a better outline on top. And my ice looks crappy compared to Ninas. :P

 

[Poké Bean]

Sorry, I totally meant to vote! They are all so amazing, I'm quite jealous of all your skills!

 

[Flowey]

Dang, I completely forgot about it xD

Is there going to be another Pixel Art contest sometime?