Blarzimafia II: Tentacle Wars [Game Over]

[Pecilia]

Are you guys paying attention here? o_o Blarz brought Fox back, what makes you think he'd let you kill him again the next day.

I'll be watching you :).



Also is Zehn not knowing his role going to be a problem every game? I'm not sure him being confirmed by Melody helps at all either tbh.

He brought Ullion back....

 

[Mana1]

Am I paying attention??

That is the question. :<

 

[Syndrome]

Ullion is not alive lol

 

[Bidoof FTW]

Alright everyone needs to simmer the **** down with this Melody wagon. Melody is a cop, she sees alignments not roles, so she isn't a threat to us right now. Fox on the other hand is confirmed scum, and we have no idea what kind of threat he poses. This push against Melody smells like an attempt to divert attention away from him which makes me think his role is pretty significant.

Either way there's absolutely no reason not to lynch this today:

[Execute] Foxrally

I can't tell if you didn't read, didnt make the connection that Melody got recruited, or you in fact are an extremist as well.

All I know is that you better hope I don't get a knife because I would stab you :)

 

[Nimsy]

[execute] Foxrally

 

[Pecilia]

I can't tell if you didn't read, didnt make the connection that Melody got recruited, or you in fact are an extremist as well.

All I know is that you better hope I don't get a knife because I would stab you :)

Melody knew Fox was scum before she got recruited, a cop role is not really dangerous for us, it's better to go for the potential extremist power role. We can execute Melody later as the potential role that Fox has can be used another night. Cop role is useless to them.

[Execute] Foxrally

 

[Candy]

Yeah I agree. Melody, converted or not, is certainly the cop role on D1. Certainly now she's working for the Extremists, but it's better if we nab someone that she has claimed to be bad back at D1.

[EXECUTE] Foxrally

 

[Syndrome]

Yeah I agree. Melody, converted or not, is certainly the cop role on D1. Certainly now she's working for the Extremists, but it's better if we nab someone that she has claimed to be bad back at D1.

[EXECUTE] Foxrally

hmmmmmmm....

 

[Syndrome]

at least someone gets it

 

[Pecilia]

I want to know why everyone thinks we should keep the converted cop role alive. So she can narrow down (or even find) the list of suspects for a power role? Fox has an unknown power, if any, but Melody we know to be an investigator, one currently sharing info with the Extremists. Guys, let's not have the Extremists kill our beloved Blarzident three nights into the game.

Because...

"The Operative - Under the command of The General and Blarzident, this individual can use their special skills to infiltrate any location and discover one player's alignment."

They can only get just that, which doesn't help them at all because they would know who is on their side and who isn't. It's useless. Fox has the potential to be something useful to the extremists and we should pounce on that before he could inflict more damage with that role.

 

[Candy]

Point taken. But eh, I can't change my vote now. <_<

Perhaps the others can vote for Melody and if the amount of votes does not suffice the Blarzident could just pick up their gavel and whack it on Melody's head.

EDIT: Ok now I get it after Pecilia's post. You can't find the Blarzident when you could only learn of alignments.

Guess the Blarzident could just slam their gavel on Fox's head if needed.

 

[Pecilia]

Ah. Pecilia does indeed have a good point, but it also begs the question: did her role change slightly upon conversion? It's such a useless and revealing conversion to not come with a few perks.

There's nothing in the original post that says the converter does so if he gets a power role or that it has a hidden power only he/she should know and frankly that would be really OP for the extremists, the conversion role is already a bit OP tbh.

 

[Who's Kiyo?]

Are we having a bloody debate about this when both the day post says the Operative was converted and Melody essentially rr'd?

Guys.

[EXECUTE] Melody

Due to the eccentricity of the game itself, her power has most likely changed or mutated into something that can be useful to extremists. Their plan is probably to even out the votes with or lynch Foxrally and use her new power as much as they can.​

...oh. A thousand pardons, your sublime tentacleness. I shall amend my mistakes at once and sacrifice a sperm whale, the eater of your aqueous worshippers, in hopes that it shall appease your divinity.

Then allow me to continue the gesture by sacrificing to you the entire country of Japan. Those heathens chop your holy servants to pieces, smear them with mayonnaise, deep-fry them, and consume them by the hundreds. They are an indecent and blasphemous people that shun the grace of your tentacleness, and their destruction would serve to glorify your name.

 

[Syndrome]

Consider this: I am under the impression that outside of FathR (who starts off with no one in his faction), no one would be able to recruit every a player to their faction every night. That would make the game unbalanced and basically the GM would have gift wrapped it to the mafia or town. There is obviously some sort of cooldown period on it, so I think it would be more dangerous to lose a role that can investigate someone every night, or worse. Which, in this case, is Melody. Therefore, the mafia, if intelligent, would vote for Foxrally. This is why Melody needs to die today. Foxrally can wait until tomorrow if he is still really being thought of as such a big threat.

 

[Bidoof FTW]

^ +1

I still think Spectrum is scum

 

[Pecilia]

Consider this: I am under the impression that outside of FathR (who starts off with no one in his faction), no one would be able to recruit every a player to their faction every night. That would make the game unbalanced and basically the GM would have gift wrapped it to the mafia or town. There is obviously some sort of cooldown period on it, so I think it would be more dangerous to lose a role that can investigate someone every night, or worse. Which, in this case, is Melody. Therefore, the mafia, if intelligent, would vote for Foxrally. This is why Melody needs to die today. Foxrally can wait until tomorrow if he is still really being thought of as such a big threat.

But when investigations only tell you an alignment it's pointless. You're trying to say that the converter would give the converted an addition to their current power rather than accept that to them it's pointless. The same can also be said about Mafia voting Melody to keep Foxrally's potential role one more night.

 

[Syndrome]

why would you bank on someone potentially having a role instead of killing the person known to have one lol...

 

[Pecilia]

why would you bank on someone potentially having a role instead of killing the person known to have one lol...

Because Melody's role is useless to the extremists what part of that do you not get? Knowing the alignment of someone is pointless when your goal is to kill everyone but the people in your group.

 

[Syndrome]

Because Melody's role is useless to the extremists what part of that do you not get? Knowing the alignment of someone is pointless when your goal is to kill everyone but the people in your group.

how would you know the role is useless unless you were an extremist yourself? what part of that do you not get? it is far safer to assume that not only did melody retained their role but got some added perk to it than "well foxrally probably has some ultra important role so lets lynch him." as I said, melody should be the priority and if foxrally still has you people riled up then just lynch him tomorrow or whatever.

you guys are really going to allow the extremists to screw us over but man idc anymore do what you feel

 

[KetsuekiR]

Spoiler:

how would you know the role is useless unless you were an extremist yourself? what part of that do you not get? it is far safer to assume that not only did melody retained their role but got some added perk to it than "well foxrally probably has some ultra important role so lets lynch him." as I said, melody should be the priority and if foxrally still has you people riled up then just lynch him tomorrow or whatever.

you guys are really going to allow the extremists to screw us over but man idc anymore do what you feel

Assuming that Melody is an investigator, her role would not help the extremists at all, since, like Pecilia mentioned, they're goal is to kill everyone not an extremist, regardless of alignment.

At the same time, if Melody was converted, she could easily provide false information (from what I gather, this is what you believe to be the case?). However, if she did and accused a modernist of being an extremist falsely, it would show up when we lynch them and then, if that is the case, we can lynch Melody the next day. As such, I think we should lynch Foxrally since he most likely has a "ultra important role".

Or, you could go the other way and lynch Melody today, letting Foxrally have another night to do what he does while Melody, who we pretty much know to be what she is, will die :P

I'm still unsure which route to take though xD