Consider this: I am under the impression that outside of FathR (who starts off with no one in his faction), no one would be able to recruit every a player to their faction every night. That would make the game unbalanced and basically the GM would have gift wrapped it to the mafia or town. There is obviously some sort of cooldown period on it, so I think it would be more dangerous to lose a role that can investigate someone every night, or worse. Which, in this case, is Melody. Therefore, the mafia, if intelligent, would vote for Foxrally. This is why Melody needs to die today. Foxrally can wait until tomorrow if he is still really being thought of as such a big threat.