how would you know the role is useless unless you were an extremist yourself? what part of that do you not get? it is far safer to assume that not only did melody retained their role but got some added perk to it than "well foxrally probably has some ultra important role so lets lynch him." as I said, melody should be the priority and if foxrally still has you people riled up then just lynch him tomorrow or whatever.
you guys are really going to allow the extremists to screw us over but man idc anymore do what you feel
Because that's unlikely and evidently going off her role being useless to the extremists makes more sense. Also we know there are 10 extremists, two of which are new. Extremists start with 6 roles, then there's the former-operative. That leaves only 2 no PR scum. 1 is unknown completely. So we have a 75% that he's a PR scum, since he's obviously not one of the two new recruits. Also even IF Melody gets an enhancement, like say figuring out their role in general, There's a 1/5(5/25) chance that they'll find a useful role in one night for them to kill the next night. Among the other 20 are Wanderers, the Fathr, Spring, the clergy (who although they do technically have a power role for the modernists it's an undetermined number and not as big as the other roles) and vanilla citizens. So 20% for them to get useful information and not get to use Fox's potential power role which again, we have a 75% that he has a power role that we can prevent the extremists from using tonight.