Patience is a virtue. A month is nothing, I posted mine before you did, still no rating!
Anyway:
@simdu: I have already said good things about your houses on MSN, if I recall, the only bad thing I can see is the outline is too thick, and shouldn't be black, they get a 9/10 on design, 7/10 on pallette. (That pesky outline!)
Your recent ones look great, but I can't really rate them too much. I'm not a fan of those sorts of tiles, so I feel I would only be biased.I will suggest making the wall of the water edge a but less square shaped, and more rounded, as water erodes things into a circular shape, just to add a more natural feeling. (I'll rate... 8/10 for both tiles and pallettes - nice work on the water pallette by the way!)
@altariaking: Shading is a bit off. You may need to look at shading again, as it seems more 2D than Pokemon tiles normally are. You wanted the best one to use? None, as they are not ready because of the shading. The roof is shaded incorrectly as well (not an insult, as shading are hard to do).
As it makes no difference where the sign goes (as it is your tile, you decide where to put it), I will rate them all equal - tiles get a 7/10 (as the shape of them is good, but the roof could do with a smoother shape, as towards the back, it looks kinda rough), and pallettesget a 6/10